Eva

On the Detroit baptism disaster: The use of the vernacular in the Catholic Church's sacraments has yet again proven to be an absolute failure.

rorate-caeli.blogspot.com

Invalid baptism leads to an avalanche of invalid sacraments

A rogue "permanent deacon" in the Archdiocese of Detroit, Mark Springer, administered invalid baptisms for 13 years. One of them was to some...

2494
Picard

There is also some much deeper problem - that is the new rites in themselfes (or precisely: the new rites in combination with the Intention resp. the determination of the ministers using them):
All the new rites, espec. the new rite of episcopal consecration but also the others, are at least (more or less) ambiguous. They do not any longer - as the old rites did - univocally express the spirit and intention of the Church but can be understood in a orthodox, traditional way but also - and very easily (and willfully so desigened!) - in a modernist resp. heretical way.
So therefore the validity of the sacramental actions, by using the new rites, is totally depending on the intention or better: determination of the minister of the sacramental act:
If he understands the words as expressing resp. intends the words to express the Catholic meaning, then the sacrament ist validly spent -- but if he understands - wants to be understood - the words in a heretical way, the sacramental act ist INVALID!!
Therefore Archbishop Lefebvre said in his famous sermon for the Episcopal Consecrations of his 4 Bishops on June, 30th 1988, that ALL SACRAMENTS spent by the MODERNISTS are DOUBTFULL because of their - doubtfull - INTENTIONS!!
(So not the rites alone and also not the intention alone ist the crucial point, but the new - ambiguous, modernist - rites in combination with the intention or better: determination of the ministers!)

Be Ye Separate

"All the new rites, espec. the new rite of episcopal consecration but also the others, are at least (more or less) ambiguous.'
Ambiguous, the same as the subversive modernist's Vatican ll documents.
.
Jesus Christ Is King.